These are some real problems experienced by 34GXP and IBM hard drives in general that we see in our lab. We are not affiliated in any way with hard drive manufacturers. All the information below is based solely on our experience and we do not make any claims regarding reliability of the specific model. We see mostly failed drives in our lab and therefore we don't have complete statistics.
At boot, windows logo appears. The bar of run passes once and the second time, the laptop reboot itself. No abnormal noise. Whene connect in an external USB adapter, the diskdrive is detected but does not seem formatted. Try spinrite. The drive is detect with two partitions. When begening the recovery, "working..." at the botom of screen and stay like that. After 3 hours, i close the laptop.
Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada
IBM(later Hitachi) is widely known in data recovery business for their line of DeskStar HDDs also known as DeathStars. These hard drives, mostly DTLA and AVER families, became infamous for their reportedly high failure rates. It is believed their problems were mainly connected with glass platters - new technology introduced by IBM in these hard drives. After some time magnetic layer started to fall off the platters creating dust inside the HDA(Head Disk Assembly) that led to massive head crashes and large number of bad sectors making the data inaccessible.
Apart from this IBM used soldering alloy of poor quality and had deficient PCB layout that caused looseness in contacts between the PCB and HDA that in turn led to firmware corruption. If you attempt to boot up from such drive or read any data from it you would get "Primary Master Hard Disk Fail" or "Operating system not found" or "USB Device malfunctioned" error or "S.M.A.R.T. Capable But Command Failed" or some other hard drive error on boot. It's critical at this point to stop any manipulations with the hard drive and send it for evaluation to our lab. Any further attempts to read these areas would shorten the drive's life and may result in further unrecoverable data loss.
The drive doesn't spin up (probably burnt logic board). The drive originally came as an external USB drive. I believe I must have mistakenly plugged the wrong power adapter, and must have first burnt the USB to IDE board, as the drive wasn't recognized by the PC but was still spinning. But after having tried unsuccesfully several times, the drive stop spinning altogether. I also tried using another USB to IDE board. Their was no spinning, although the PC understood a HD drive was attached (but couldn't access any volume).
Lincoln, Nebraska, USA
Another common data loss problem for all IBM-Hitachi hard drives is burnt components on the circuit board(PCB). Hard drives are very vulnerable to power surges and bad power supply unit combined with power streak is usually enough to burn spindle driver chip on the PCB. If this occurs the computer would reboot itself, you would normally notice acrid smoke coming from your PC and upon power on the drive would not spin up at all.
If this is the case you can try PCB swap from another IBM drive of the same model but the chances of successful data recovery are close to 0. Moreover, newer drives sometimes "lock" incompatible PCB and after that PCB won't be able to work on the original donor drive. The fact is that most modern drives have special parameters in the ROM chip on the PCB called adaptives which are unique for this particular drive and these parameters should correspond to the HDA PCB was manufactured with. In our lab we are able to read ROM and NVRAM contents even from burnt logic boards and write it to the compatible donor board. After that donor PCB becomes fully compatible with the damaged drive and often data can be recovered after that.
There is one more problem that is typical for all IBM drives: bad sectors. After some period of time magnetic media the platters are covered with starts to degrade and bad sectors appear. Whenever the drive hits such unreadable bad sector it could start freezing, scratching, ticking and sometimes loud clicking. If you happen to hear that unmistakable repeating scratching noise from your drive this is exactly your case. This leads to further damage to the surface and causes more data loss.
I tried both hooking my drive up to a PC with Linux as the OS and a live PCB swap on an XP with the OS in sleep mode but with no success. Your website indicates the firmware is on the platter and if that is corrupt, it seems to make sense that it's not a problem I cannot fix myself. Model is 34GXP.
Pembroke, Ontario, Canada
As soon as you start experiencing such symptoms while reading important files stop the drive immediately and send it to a data recovery lab. Any further attempts would just add up to the problems. In our lab we use special imaging hardware tools that are capable of reading raw sector data ignoring checksum check. That's usually the only way to retrieve as much data as possible from these LBAs.
Another quite common symptom Hitachi drives have is clicking or knocking sound. The drive spins up and the head starts clicking right away: , . Most often this a sign of a bad head and the drive needs heads swapped from a donor, but before doing any clean room work, it is very important to perform accurate diagnostics and eliminate a chance of possible firmware corruption that sometimes can also cause clicking.
If you experience any of the symptoms described above with your IBM 34GXP please feel free to contact us to get upfront quote on data recovery from your failed drive.
If you hear your IBM hard drive making some other unusual noises visit our Hard Drive Sounds page for more examples.
We have seen a number of websites lately cloning information from our pages.
Stay away from those companies. They can steal information but they can't steal knowledge and experience.
Ottawa | Hull | Gatineau | Montreal | Toronto | Quebec | Vancouver | Calgary | Edmonton | Winnipeg | Hamilton
London | Kitchener | Halifax | Victoria | Windsor | Oshawa | Saskatoon | Sherbrooke | Kingston | Missisauga
Nepean | Barrie | Thunder Bay | Sudbury | Kanata | North Bay | BC | St. John's | Colchester| Newfoundland | PEI
Ontario | Quebec | Alberta | Saskatchewan | Manitoba | Alberta | British Columbia | Nova Scotia | New Brunswick